Field coaching
By Skillet Team
·
4 min read

Jim O’Day, who has spent more than 30 years in pharmaceutical learning, on why commercial training stops at knowledge and what it takes for new behaviors to stick.
Did the launch training change how reps run their calls? Six months later, are they still using the new approach? Do they understand why the change mattered in the first place?
Pharma and medtech commercial teams already have plenty of training. Launch modules, certifications and LMS completion reports are standard across the industry. But what happens when completion is the main thing being measured?
We sat down with Jim O’Day, who has spent more than 30 years in pharmaceutical learning across oncology, hematology, cell therapy and primary care at three companies, many of those years leading sales teams. When we asked him where commercial training fails reps, he started with design. “The training is often designed for speed,” he said. “Speed to delivery, speed to completion. It doesn’t necessarily challenge someone’s thinking and force them to grow and evolve.”
Why does training stop at knowledge?
Jim borrows an answer from change management. The ADKAR model, developed by Prosci founder Jeff Hiatt, describes five stages a person moves through in order: Awareness of why a change is needed, Desire to take part, Knowledge of how to change, Ability to do it, and Reinforcement to keep doing it.
Most commercial training starts at the third stage. “Most trainings don’t focus on helping an individual have awareness as to why they need to do it, and help them develop the desire to actually want to do it,” Jim said. “They focus on the management piece of it: delivering it, making sure they get it done, and then checking the box.”
Reps learn the label, the data and the approved messages. In Jim’s words, “The failure is where the application and the sustainment comes in.” Research on training transfer, going back to Baldwin and Ford’s 1988 review, points the same way: what people learn in a course often fades from their day-to-day work without practice and follow-up.
Jim has watched the industry pay for that gap for decades. “We spend billions of dollars across the globe on development,” he said, “and we’re still doing the same thing over and over again year after year.”
How awareness and desire get built
Consider a rep with ten years in the territory who is asked to change how they open a call with an oncologist. They might feel they don’t need it. They might not have time. Jim calls this a personal identity trigger: “How good I already am. I don’t need to do this. This is a waste of my time.”
Jim’s answer is to give reps somewhere to practice where nobody’s watching. “You have the psychological safety to challenge yourself without anybody looking over your shoulder and judging,” he said. He’s seen it work on the skeptics, too. Reps who only showed up because their manager told them to tend to “find it’s not as scary as they thought.”
Reinforcement is harder. Even a manager who rides with each of twelve reps twice a month leaves them alone most of the time. “There is significantly more time with them out on their own with no supervision, no guidance and making their own decisions,” Jim said. He sees this as the biggest gap: behavior change takes “multiple touches over time,” and most organizations don’t have a way to provide them.
Rethinking what commercial training is for
This is where tools built for practice are worth considering. Skillet gives reps AI roleplay conversations with realistic HCP avatars, built around a team’s own products and scenarios, with written and spoken feedback after each attempt. The idea, as Jim put it, is to “put the hard work into the practice so that when you’re in the hard situation, it becomes easy.”
Skillet’s Ride Along feature lets a rep talk through a call plan before a visit and get pushed the way a manager would push them. Jim described the questions it asks: “Is that really the objective? Based on the data that’s available, have you considered this?”
“It’s by no means a replacement for the live ride-along,” he said. “But it is a really cool opportunity for the representatives to challenge themselves.” To complete the ADKAR loop, reps reinforce their learning in the real meeting they’re about to walk into.
For commercial and L&D leaders, the larger question may be what training is measured on. Completion shows that reps saw the material. Whether they use it six months later depends on awareness, desire and repeated practice.
Skillet gives commercial teams a way to keep practice and feedback going after the module ends.
PRACTICE IN SKILLET
Run practice conversations as AI roleplay, built from your own label and messaging.
S
Skillet Team